Generational opportunity to own the very tip of magical Fairy Island! This shore colonial with 250' of lake frontage offers a nearly 270-degree panorama of beautiful Lake Mahopac. Boasting water views from every room of the house, the entire property is level to the water in a fenced and private setting. Fairy Island, a one-of-a-kind private island shared with only 3 other homes, is connected to the shore by a gated causeway. Recreational space surrounds 3 sides of this expansive property to offer lakeside dining, lounging, lawn sports, and a fire pit at water's edge. It features 3 boat docks for fishing, swimming and water sports of every variety. 4 bdrms plus guest rm offer ample space for visitors. Oversized living rm w/fireplace; 3-season sun porch; primary bdrm/w fireplace & dressing rm, 2.5 full baths and jacuzzi w/water view. Close to trains; 70-min drive from NYC; tennis, hiking, running trails and 2 golf courses 5 mins away.